Hip replacement surgery has become increasingly popular as a solution for chronic hip pain caused by conditions like osteoarthritis. However, not everyone is a good candidate for this procedure. In this blog post, we will discuss who may not be well-suited for hip replacement surgery and why.
As a general rule, not everyone is an ideal candidate for hip replacement surgery. Hip infection, morbid obesity, and other infections may disqualify some from hip replacement surgery. Consult a doctor to see if the procedure is right for you.
I’m here to help you navigate your option of hip surgery. My 30-year background as a chiropractor has been complemented by my training in ergonomics. I have written a book on maintaining good posture, presented on the subject on nationwide TV, and devised multiple solutions to support optimal posture and sitting comfort. I also successfully crowdfunded the development of my newest innovation, a collection of ergonomic seat cushions, through Kickstarter. With this wealth of expertise, I am confident in my ability to offer practical advice that can minimize or even eliminate your discomfort.
Good Candidate vs. Not-So-Ideal Candidate for Replacement Surgery
First, let’s define good candidates for hip replacement surgery. These are individuals who have tried non-surgical treatments, such as physical therapy and medications, but still experience significant hip pain that interferes with daily activities. Osteoarthritis is often the primary reason for hip replacement surgery, and good candidates typically have advanced joint degeneration.
On the other hand, not everyone with hip pain is a good candidate for replacement surgery. Certain factors may make the procedure more risky or less likely to provide long-term relief. So, who is not a good candidate for hip replacement surgery?
I’ve written a complete hands-on review about the best seat cushion after hip surgery, and here are some of the shocking issues I ran into in this post!
Those with Severe Medical Conditions
People with severe medical conditions or uncontrolled chronic diseases may not be suitable candidates for hip replacement surgery. Conditions like heart disease, lung disease, or poorly managed diabetes can increase the risk of complications during and after surgery. It’s essential to consult with a doctor and surgeon to discuss any health concerns and determine if hip replacement surgery is appropriate.
All Day Comfort & Support
Insufficient Bone Quality or Density | Osteoarthritis
For a hip replacement to be successful, the patient’s bone quality and density must be strong enough to support the new joint replacement. Individuals with low bone density or conditions like osteoporosis may not be good candidates for hip replacement surgery as their bones may not provide adequate support for the implant, leading to complications or implant failure.
Infections or Skin Conditions Near the Hip Joint
If a person has an active infection or a chronic skin condition near the hip joint, they may not be a suitable candidate for hip replacement surgery. An active infection can increase the risk of infection in the new joint, while skin conditions can create challenges for the surgical incision site, increasing the risk of complications.
It’s important to have realistic expectations about the outcome of hip replacement surgery. While many patients experience significant relief from hip pain and improved mobility, not everyone will achieve the same results. Patients should discuss their expectations with their doctor and surgeon to ensure they understand the potential benefits and limitations of hip replacement surgery.
Axial Ergonomic Seat Cushion® | Seat Chair Wedge
Quick Guide: A 30-Second Summary
Axial Ergonomic Seat Cushion® | Seat Chair Wedge
Alternative Surgical Options | Surgeon
Some individuals may not be ideal candidates for traditional hip replacement surgery but could still benefit from alternative surgical options. For example, minimally invasive hip surgery, such as anterior hip replacement, can be a suitable option for some patients. It’s essential to discuss these alternatives with a surgeon to determine the best course of action for your specific situation.
I’ve written a complete hands-on review about the best sitting position for back pain, and here is what I tested best with my back pain patients.
Problems with Superpath Hip Replacement
Superpath hip replacement is a minimally invasive hip surgery that preserves more of the hip joint’s natural structure than traditional hip replacements. Despite its benefits, this surgical procedure has certain limitations. For example, a patient with hip infection or sepsis might not be an ideal candidate for a Superpath hip replacement because the risk of complications is higher in such cases. Moreover, some individuals with severe hip deformities or extensive joint damage may not benefit from this type of hip replacement surgery.
Total Hip Replacement Indications and Contraindications
Total hip replacement surgery is a type of joint replacement surgery that involves replacing the damaged hip joint with an artificial joint. Indications for hip replacement include severe hip pain that interferes with daily activities, limited hip joint mobility, and failed non-surgical treatments. Total hip replacement contraindications physiotherapy include active infections, poor bone quality, and significant medical conditions that increase the risk of complications during orthopedic surgery.
Indications for Hip Replacement Candidates | Joint Replacement | Knee Replacement
Hip replacement surgery is typically recommended for patients who have arthritis or other degenerative conditions that cause chronic hip pain and limited mobility. However, not everyone is a good candidate for hip replacement surgery. Some of the factors that may make a patient unsuitable for this procedure include:
- Young age: While there is no strict age limit for undergoing joint replacement surgery, younger patients may be encouraged to explore alternative treatments, such as hip resurfacing or anterior hip replacement, before considering a total hip replacement.
- Inadequate bone quality: Patients with poor bone quality due to osteoporosis or other medical conditions may not be suitable candidates for hip replacement surgery.
- Obesity: Overweight patients may be at a higher risk of complications during and after hip replacement surgery. Weight loss may be recommended before considering surgery.
- Active infection: Patients with an active infection in the hip joint or other parts of the body may not be suitable candidates for hip replacement surgery until the infection is treated.
Total Hip Replacement Surgery Contraindications Physiotherapy | Hip Surgery | Surgeons
Physiotherapy plays a crucial role in the recovery and rehabilitation process following hip replacement surgery. However, some patients may not benefit from physiotherapy after undergoing a total hip replacement. These patients may have contraindications such as:
- Severe neurological conditions that limit the patient’s ability to participate in rehabilitation exercises
- Uncontrolled medical conditions that pose a significant risk to the patient’s safety during physical therapy sessions
All Day Comfort & Support
Axial Designs™ Seat Cushion
100% Natural Latex (Molded)
Isometric Grippy Vegan Leather
3D Breathable Fabric
Can You Still Have Arthritis After Hip Replacement Surgery? | Hip Pain
Although joint replacement surgery, including hip and knee replacement, can alleviate pain and improve mobility in patients with arthritis, it is important to understand that the procedure does not cure arthritis. Patients who undergo hip replacement surgery may still experience pain or discomfort in other joints affected by arthritis. Additionally, it is possible for the artificial joint to wear out over time, which could lead to the need for revision surgery.
Hip replacement surgery can greatly improve the quality of life for patients suffering from hip pain due to arthritis or other degenerative conditions. However, not everyone is a good candidate for this procedure. Factors such as age, bone quality, obesity, and active infection can all impact a patient’s suitability for hip replacement surgery. If you are considering hip replacement surgery, it is essential to consult with an experienced orthopedic surgeon who can guide you best.